If you’re shopping for a new electric roaster, the most important features you should look for are power, interface, and size. As well as portability. To help you out with picking the best electric roaster, I’ve put together a list of options. The sooner you figure out what you want, the sooner you get to start planning your Thanksgiving dinner.
There are many great ways to roast a chicken or a turkey. Whether you’re hosting a Thanksgiving dinner or cooking for any holiday feast, a roaster oven or electric roaster is a convenient way to prepare meals. Keeping the meat moist and juicy is the goal in roasting birds. An electric roaster is excellent at perfecting the roasting temperature. So your bird doesn’t come out undercooked, yet not dry.
With a comprehensive buying guide, you should be able to shop for the best electric roaster that suits your needs and style. But before we begin, let’s have an overview of the products I picked. Then, you can decide early which one is ideal for you.
Our Top Picks: Best Roaster Roasters
|Best Overall||Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven||– 17.5 x 10.5 x 24 inches|
– Stainless steel- 0.17 lbs
– Has a temperature range of 150
– 450 degrees Fahrenheit
|Runner Up for Best Overall||Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid||– 23.3 x 15.6 x 11.8 inches|
– Steel Material
– 0.17 lbs
– 1,450 watts
|Best Premium Roaster||Breville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven||– 18.5 x 26 x 17 inches|
– Brushed Stainless Steel
– 38.9 lbs
– Has 13 cooking functions
|High-capacity Roaster Oven||Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven||– 23.5 x 17.5 x 9.8 inches|
– Has a temperature range of 150-450 degrees Fahrenheit
– 1,450 watts
– Has removable steel rack and pan
– With 1-year limited warranty
|Perfect for a Secondary Oven||NESCO MWR18-13 Roaster Oven||– 23.75 x 16 x 13.11 inches|
– 14 lbs- 1,450 watts
– Has a removable enamel cook well
– Has a temperature range of 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
The Best Electric Roaster
Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven – Best Overall
Looking for a roaster with a bigger cooking capacity at a low price would be made easy by the Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven. This electric roaster has one of the best features out there. With a 22-quart capacity, you can fit turkeys up to 28 pounds with minimal fuss. All thanks to its lift-out rack and domed, self-basting lid. It also has an adjustable thermostat from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. This means you can make creamy soups, casseroles, and side dishes. You can also use it to warm up foods or next servings.
Despite the large roasting size, the Hamilton Beach electric roaster is lightweight. The removable pan and stainless exterior make clean up a bit easier. This electric roaster’s serving capacity makes an excellent choice if you’re looking to cook for big festivities where you may feed eight or more people.
– Has removable pan
– Easy to clean
– Large capacity
– Has adjustable thermostat
– A customer review says it has a missing light indicator
Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid – Runner Up, Best Overall
If you’re searching for an electric roaster with superior functionality, the Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid could be another to consider on the list. I like this as not only can you roast in it, you can also make stews, cook rice, veggies, and soups. You can also fit a whole 22-pound turkey and expect it to be thoroughly cooked. All thanks to the 1,450 watts power. This appliance will keep your food deliciously warm.
The Oster roaster’s arched lid is generous with space, and doesn’t come in contact with the meat while it’s cooking. Aside from this, you can cook three different dishes in one go as you have enough space to fit two or more meals at a time. It has a small LED indicator that lights up when the unit is heated and ready for use. This way, you’ll be able to keep track of your cooking, and watch your meat come out crispy and juicy.
– Has a handy LED indicator
– Arched lid offers space for large meals
– Easy heat adjustment
– Has a scratch proof-cooking pan
– Exterior gets hot; requires careful handling
– Cleaning takes more effort
Breville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven – Best Premium
Looking for a multi talented choice? The Breville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven might just be the best when it comes to interface. The way I look at this roaster, it doesn’t seem to be the standard roaster I know. But it makes a solid choice for different cooking purposes. While most of the other appliances can only roast, this one can broil, air fry, dehydrate and toast.
With the Breville oven, you can roast a 14-pound turkey. There’s also room for 12-cup muffin trays, and you can fit a 9×13-inch fry pan. An addition to the package includes a sliding mesh tray for easy release. While on the hefty side in terms of price, its impressive 13 cooking functions are the best perk. True to its name, this appliance has smart connectivity that’s accessible via the LCD display.
– Boats 13 cooking functions
– Has a free sliding mesh tray
– Smart appliance
– Hefty price
Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven – High-Capacity
I like investing in appliances that lessen the hassle in the kitchen. If you’re like me, the Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven could make your life better. It’s going to help you save time and leave you with fewer chores — the Rival roaster will do the job for you. With this machine, you don’t need to open the lid and stir what’s inside. It has a self-basting lid that allows vapors to travel throughout the oven. So, food comes out tender and tasty as it self-cooks in its gravy.
For smaller diners, this roaster is one of the sweetest options as it can accommodate an 18-pound bird. It features a graded knob that allows you to adjust the heat up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Much like most electric roasters, you can also preserve the warmth of the food by setting it to 200 degrees Fahrenheit until it’s ready to be served.
– Has more space for large meals
– Removable steel rack pan
– Has non stick surface for easy release
– Comes with 1-year warranty
– Doesn’t have an LED indicator
– Cleaning the pan is tough
NESCO MWR18-13 Roaster Oven – Perfect for a Secondary Oven
Mastering the ways of cooking for the holiday seasons may require a bit of help from the NESCO MWR18-13 Roaster Oven. This UI- approved machine works for your everyday cooking needs. It’s a nice second oven for busy kitchens where a regular oven might need assistance. The NESCO roaster saves time, and heats up evenly. It has a “keep warm” setting that preserves the warmth of your food until it’s set for serving guests.
This machine has removable enameled cook well and cool touch handles, which make it convenient to use everyday. A few downsides: it can take up a lot of space, and can be tough to clean. You might also experience turning the machine on by accident. Aside from these, it has no indicator that alerts you when it’s on or off.
– Time-saving and heats up evenly
– Great everyday roaster and for Holiday Season
– Has “keep warm” to preserve warmth
– Perfect as a secondary oven
– Takes up space
– Tough to clan
– Has no indicator
Buying Guide: How to Pick the Right Roaster Oven
Electric rosters come in varying sizes, materials, and power. And since they are meant to be more convenient than an oven, the portability and serving size of an electric roaster should be one of the things you must look into, among several other factors.
Size and Capacity
The first factor to look for is the size and the capacity of an electric roaster to accommodate your desired serving size. If you’re aiming to roast a larger bird to feed six to eight people, a 16 or 18-quart electric roaster would be a good size to start with. However, if you’re feeding more than ten people, you can up your size to 22 or 24 quarts.
Some electric roasters come in as little as 6-quart, and they’re not built for turkeys at all. They are great for cooking soups, spices, and roasting vegetables. But if you’re single or cooking for two people, a 6-quart electric roaster would do good.
Enameled steel and stainless steel are two of the most common materials for electric roasters. Stainless steel electric roasters have good heat distribution and retention. They are also more lightweight, which makes them easy to transport and convenient to carry anywhere.
If you want a more premium feel, enameled steel has better heat distribution and retention. This means your food will also come out evenly, while maximizing high energy efficiency. However, you’ll need stronger ceps to carry them.
A good lid should be the same material used in the construction of the electric roaster. The lid of your roaster should be able to retain heat, is easy to clean, and durable. High dome lids often come in handy when roasting larger birds. This way, the meat doesn’t come in contact with and sticks to the lid while it’s roasting.
Self-basting lids are also common. This type of lid helps recirculate moisture, which keeps your meat from drying out. The spikes or ridges on the lid help trap steam within and draw it back onto the food.
A great temperature function with a wide range of settings is best for precision cooking. Electric roasters with a greater temperature range allow you to maximize your appliance. It would be best to avoid an electric roaster with a single on/off dial if you don’t want to complicate things.
You can search for roasters that are able to reach 450 degrees Fahrenheit. I find roasters with a “keep warm” function, and a defrosting setting versatile. But I suggest you refer to which settings you like using the most and make a decision according to your needs.
To be able to maximize your electric roaster is a good indication of a quality appliance. The wattage of your electric roaster usually scales with the temperature range. To get that nice, crispy skin for your turkey, get a roaster with higher wattage. This way, you can have extended high-heat cooking.
An electric roaster should be easily transportable everywhere you go. So it’s a good idea to get a roaster that you can carry. You can bring a lightweight roaster to your picnic day out, and potlucks. As for storage purposes, your electric roaster should be easily taken out of the cabinet without a struggle and put back just as easily.
Some roasters in our list are heftier than a regular-sized one. But if you want to really maximize portability, a more compact roaster would save up space in your cabinet.
Controls and Interface
Electric roasters are simple devices that you can easily manipulate. Many roaster ovens have a single dial that allows you to operate at ease. So no complicated features here. But one of the things you may want to look into is a heat indicator light. This enables you to monitor your cooking so your roast doesn’t burn.
Some roasters even come with a clock, and the best ones come with a range of buttons. Features like these are built for roaster ovens with a greater variety of cooking features.
The electric roaster you’re going to buy should match your budget. Our best pick is under $100, which works great at cooking anything an oven can. If you want to splurge on something higher-priced, it’s important to know that you’re only getting the appliance that you need for the price that you pay.
Functions of Electric Roaster
One of the best things about having an electric roaster is that you can use it in all kitchens. Whether you are a professional chef or a beginner, this roaster is designed to be an easy-to-use tool for everyone. There are far more things you can do with your roaster. And we recommend this to anyone who grew tired of eating fast food and wants to make an easy at-home meal.
Properly cooked meat
Admit, we’ve all had this dilemma where your meat is just not the right texture or moist you want it to be. Sometimes, it’s in the lack of experience with cooking, and other times, it’s in the oven. The reason your meat comes out dry, tasteless, or overcooked at times is that you don’t have an efficient tool to do the trick.
Your steak has a better chance of coming out juicy with a good electric roaster. Its small bottom, deep construction, and heaters on the sides help in achieving properly cooked meat.
Adds cooking space
Being the versatile cooking tool that it is, an electric roaster can be used for different purposes. You can experiment with different recipes with it if you want to become a chef. If baking is what you love doing, you can even use it to bake pretty symmetrical cakes, while making something else in the oven. In short, you can use this and others altogether to make delicious meals.
Cook and bake anything
Getting all the functions we need is what we want in a kitchen appliance. Most electric roasters will allow you to bake and cook a wide variety of dishes. It’s very useful for slow-cooking and warming up food, and anything you could think of, really.
While one of our recommendations costs more than a regular electric roaster, most of them are pocket-friendly. The energy efficiency it brings makes it an attractive appliance to many, as it uses far less power if you compare it to the convection oven.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best electric roaster to buy?
There are many great options to choose from in the market. But we recommend the Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven and the Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid. Both are lightweight, easy to use, and workhorse appliances you must add to your kitchen.
What size electric roaster do I need?
The size of your electric roaster depends on your personal preference. But a roaster oven must be large enough to hold the cuts of meat. As I’ve mentioned previously, many roasters in the market have sizes ranging from 16 to 22 quarts in capacity. But you’ll also come across some that are as small as 6 quarts in size. A 6-quart roaster oven is too small and not designed to roast a whole turkey.
Is Turkey better in an oven or roaster?
An electric roaster cooks a turkey faster than a regular oven. But do use a meat thermometer to ensure that your meat is properly cooked. When you cook a turkey in an electric roaster, it comes out moist, though less brown than a turkey roasted in a regular oven.
How long should a turkey cook in a roaster?
Place your turkey in the roaster, the side with the breast should face up. Rub it with some butter and then season it with salt and pepper. Once done, cover the roaster and leave it at 400 degrees for 30 minutes. Adjust heat to 325 degrees and let it cook for another 3 to 4 hours until a thermometer reads 165 degrees in the thickest part of the turkey’s thigh.
Are roaster ovens worth it?
Roaster ovens are convenient countertop appliances. They provide extra cooking capacity. And the best thing about it is that they are more compact than a conventional oven. They’re very energy-efficient, so you need not worry about it heating up your kitchen.
My favorites are the Hamilton Beach 22-Quart Roaster Oven and the Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid. Both are lightweight, have self-basting lids, and are great for hosting a big Thanksgiving dinner. But if you have a budget and want a true workhorse, the Breville BOV900BSSUSC The Smart Toaster Oven could be a smart choice for cooking diverse food.
Another great option could be the Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven. This machine helps to limit the time you spend on cooking and is excellent at preserving the warmth of food. Or you may opt for the NESCO MWR18-13 Roaster Oven, which has a “keep warm” function that does the same thing as the Rival. And it serves well for an everyday cooking session.
I hope you find this review and guide helpful in finding the best electric roaster for you and your family. Don’t miss out on the latest discounts on these awesome brands and models by checking out the prices above. Good luck, and happy roasting!